Abstaining here. I find SMW to be overrated, and I don't know enough about this Final Fantasy to vote for it.

Haha.

Another round where there is no loser. Both games deserve praise. Life is Strange stayed with me longer after playing than Undertale, but it would be completely understandable if it loses to Undertale.

BG2 is my alltime favourite RPG. It might have to do with the modding community still being active some two decades later, too. It's a terrific game. If it loses to Symphony of the Night, it'll likely be a worthy opponent though. I couldn't get into the Castlevania games, but from what I've heard, S...

I could not get into ICO. I tried, but it didn't grab me. TTYD is probably the closest thing to a perfect Mario RPG.

Ooh, this is a tough one. Love Superstar Saga, but Dragon Age is a great RPG. Worked well for me as a Baldur's Gate spiritual successor when it came out. I think I'll give DA the nod here.

Good luck, BG. If you lose to GoW, it'll at least be a worthy loss.

Both great games, but Undertale is something special.

C'mon BG2.... you're close to knocking the OG 3D platformer out.

BG2 is still my favourite RPG. I haven't played the unrelated sequel, but GOTY awards be damned. It can't surpass the originals.