BotW was a really great game, but Dark Souls was just utterly phenomenal.

Breath of the Wild is just more Zelda. :shock: Breath of the Wild is the most different Zelda since Ocarina of Time took the series into 3D. I would even argue that it's the first truly successful execution of the Zelda series "mission" in 3D, which is why I'm voting for it here. The worl...

Breath of the Wild is just more Zelda. Ironic that this is the reason I'm not voting for it. I wanted more Zelda and ended up getting something different and then the same thing happened again with TotK and now we haven't had a 3D Zelda Dungeon style game since Skyward Sword which was 13 years ago....

Damn this really has me stumped. BB is my favourite arcade game of all time, so many good memories of playing it with my late mother and with my sister and brother-in-law. I simply adore it. Meanwhile SMB is platforming perfection, I can't think of any other games where I could die 100+ times in the...

Kong Wen wrote: ↑20 Feb 2024 02:44 Ooh, a console wars clash of introductions to two now-classic series: one series of mostly good games, and one series where the original DKC is the only good entry.

Most people say DKC2 is the best entry, what didn't you like about it?

Battle of the pre-rendered graphics!

Sharecrow wrote: ↑05 Feb 2024 20:12 Sonic 2 will lose this one but not lose my vote. Fantastic game and even somehow incorporated coop.

Little kid/younger sibling coop maybe...

RE4 did far too much for gaming to pick Dead Space. Though both are brilliant games! I have about 25 playthroughs of RE4 across 5 or 6 platforms. Both titles had excellent remakes too.

Sunshine needs to bugger off out of this BGE. It's by no means a bad game but among the weaker 3D Mario titles.

Finally getting to play Sonic CD on the Gamecube when Gems collection came out, I was very excited to finally have another Megadrive era Sonic platformer. I was underwhelmed. The level design is messy. It feels cluttered. My least favourite of the 4 main sonic platformers from that time.