I think I'm going to throw my weight behind the superior Baldur's Gate 2 elsewhere in these polls, and vote for God of War here. God of War is not just an excellent game in its own right, but also a masterclass on how to rescue a stale and toxic mascot and turn him into a compelling characte.

Warsong (perhaps the best Genesis game) is much more compelling to me than a remake of an admittedly good NES game. You may be thinking of Metroid: Zero Mission, as Super Metroid is not a remake of any of the first one game. It takes place after the events in the NES game and the whole Prime trilog...

Wind Waker is a good, cute refinement of the by-then narrative-driven Zelda games. Nintendo understood that it was in their best interests to stylize (and simplify) their graphical style rather than just trying to make Ocarina of Time look better. It worked, to a degree. Final Fantasy IV represents ...

Interesting match-up between two 2015 games about caring for people.

Portal balances snappy pacing and story progression with great individual puzzle gameplay and difficulty ramping. Nice and tight, never really sags like its sequel does in parts. Also responsible for a host of "portal mechanics" showing up in other games across genres, for better or worse....

I mean, Final Fantasy VI.

In many ways, this is a poetic match-up. The Legend of Zelda is pure gameplay, emptied of plot. Yes, there is a loose over-arching story, but no plot. Literally having no plot is part of the design philosophy of the game—you're in an open world, and you have to decide where to go next. Even tackling...

This is another tough one, although not as tough as the DOOM vs. Super Meat Boy poll. Super Mario World is my favourite Mario game (I don't need to specify 2D, since the best game in the series must by default be a 2D game), but it's not a quantum leap ahead of Super Mario Bros 3, which largely did ...

Yeah I need to think about this. These are both excellent, arguably perfect games. Both well-deserving of a spot on many top-10 lists. I'm happy that either one of them gets to advance.

Not a super-easy vote for me even though I personally prefer one of these games over the other a great deal. I'm not shackled to my own personal preferences when evaluating a game's quality. Mega Man 2 is probably tied with MMX for my favourite game in the series, with MM9 very very close behind, bu...