Ooh, a console wars clash of introductions to two now-classic series: one series of mostly good games, and one series where the original DKC is the only good entry.

Wow, this is quite a match-up for the Bottom 112. These are both titans. I'm giving the edge to Portal for being a tighter experience and a newer/fresher experience. RDR definitely gets points for being big and for the setting, but it's GTA in the wild west, which is exactly what people expected fro...

Oh great, the other Shadowrun is also up against a great game that I love.

At least this poll had the good graces to match the two Genesis games together.

I shouldn't find this vote as difficult as I do lol Shadowrun is a fantastic RPG. Great systems, atmosphere, music, etc. But Lemmings is the OG "solve the world around your guys" puzzler and arguably no one has done it better. It's fitting that this game is fighting for its life a day or s...

With apologies to the cute Shining series progenitor, in these later rounds I'm casting votes for the strong narrative exemplars whenever I can, especially when they're up against stripped-down games that aren't the best in their genre or series. Shining is a cute curiosity, a beginner-friendly dung...

Sharecrow wrote: ↑16 Feb 2024 22:00 Arg! I don’t get it.. but I often favor unpopular games so maybe it’s just another instance of that.

I have a feeling 100% of the people on the forum who have played the game voted for it.

Just got back from a weekend trip during which I chatted with my dad extensively about his 160 hours playing Breath of the Wild. He just got the quest from Impa to go seek out the 4 beasts, so he's on the Zora kingdom's doorstep. 160 hours in.

Happy birthday from the east coast, Shoe! Hope it's a great one.
Man, a February birthday in the 'Peg. How does that usually work out for ya?

Actually a really strong matchup if we had people in this community who actually cared about FGC or were good at fighting games lol, but due to context and bias we don't. That's not to take anything away from Hollow Knight, as I've praised it to the hills multiple times in here. But these are both e...

Yeah this was a tough decision but I had to throw in with Link to the Past, especially knowing DOOM is still in the top 16. I can live with the idea of DOOM carrying the DOOM torch.