Top 128 Tie-Breaker 2/8: Ico the Ninja

[This Old Neon]

Here's a tie-breaker! Only one of these two games will advance to the Top 64.

28 - Ico - 2001 - PS2
60 - Mark of the Ninja - 2012 - PC/X360

You have one vote. The poll will be open for 4 days.

[Sharecrow]

"Oom-Fwa? Oom-Fwa?"

[The Shoemaker]

Funny that both "Ico" games are in tiebreaker limbo. I wonder if the Last Guardian was already out if it too would be in a tie-breaker.

[Turai]

Mark of the ninja is a great stealth game (with a shitty art style) versus Ico, a terrible game that takes the worst part of any game (escort missions) and turns it into its entire game.

My vote is a given.

[Kong Wen]

This was a trickier choice for me, but I went with ICO. I think it's a great 3D execution of an interesting game mode (escort/puzzle-platformer). It also has an interesting world and dark atmosphere. Mark of the NInja is certainly worthy of progressing, too.

[Kong Wen]

The tie-breaker has ended in another tie, so Ico (ranked 28) will retain its position over Mark of the Ninja (ranked 60).