This Old Neon Forum

Could we do something along the lines of best series?

Aka Mario, The Legend of Zelda, Metroid, Megaman, Grand Theft Auto, Borderland, ~ Souls. And we'd vote on the series as a whole instead of an individual game.

Pluvius wrote:Best game that made it through at least three preliminary rounds.

Any three rounds before the Top 128, so a game that debuted in the first round and made it to the 4th, plus a game that debuted in the 3rd round and made it to the 6th, etc?

Kong Wen wrote:

Pluvius wrote:Best game that made it through at least three preliminary rounds.

Any three rounds before the Top 128, so a game that debuted in the first round and made it to the 4th, plus a game that debuted in the 3rd round and made it to the 6th, etc?

Yes. Change the number of rounds as needed to get a reasonable number of entries.

Rob

Slurmee wrote:Best RPG

Only possible if I keep it to the few highest-seeded games that I know are RPGs.

Slurmee wrote:Best Gen 7 game

Sure, that'd be possible.

Han Solo wrote:Best Star Wars game.

Sure! Not many were nominated.

VictorViper wrote:I'd like to see a non-franchise/one-off contest. If I never see a Metroid/Mario/Pokémon game again, it'll be too soon.

You won't like the results.

Sharecrow wrote:Would best game by producer make sense? Like best Sega game, best Capcom, etc?

That would be hard to track, but as with the genre/RPG suggestion above, I could just eyeball the highest-seeded games.

Slurmee wrote:Could we do something along the lines of best series?

Aka Mario, The Legend of Zelda, Metroid, Megaman, Grand Theft Auto, Borderland, ~ Souls. And we'd vote on the series as a whole instead of an individual game.

Sure thing!

Kong Wen wrote:

VictorViper wrote:I'd like to see a non-franchise/one-off contest. If I never see a Metroid/Mario/Pokémon game again, it'll be too soon.

You won't like the results.

Additionally, here are a couple of games that could be included, unless there's resistance:

Super Meat Boy, successor—not sequel—to the Flash game "Meat Boy"
The Guardian Legend, sequel to the MSX game Guardic, but honestly, who cares?

Kong Wen wrote:

Kong Wen wrote:

VictorViper wrote:I'd like to see a non-franchise/one-off contest. If I never see a Metroid/Mario/Pokémon game again, it'll be too soon.

You won't like the results.

Additionally, here are a couple of games that could be included, unless there's resistance:

Super Meat Boy, successor—not sequel—to the Flash game "Meat Boy"
The Guardian Legend, sequel to the MSX game Guardic, but honestly, who cares?

I'm not concerned with results, I'd just like to see a contest including games that haven't become household names.

As for the examples listed, I'd be just fine with remakes/de-flashes/whatever in place of (or in competition with) the originals.

Will we be running 1 side event at a time or multiple side events?

Can we do a game of the year as well?

Slurmee wrote:Can we do a game of the year as well?

Might require new nominations for that.

The Shoemaker wrote:

Slurmee wrote:Can we do a game of the year as well?

Might require new nominations for that.

What games that came out this year that deserve a GoTY nomination didn't get nominated this year?