This Old Neon Forum

Here's a tie-breaker! One of these three games will advance to the Top 128.

1992 - Sonic the Hedgehog 2 - Genesis/MD
1994 - Uncharted Waters: New Horizons - SNES
2008 - Valkyria Chronicles - PS3/PC

You have one vote. The poll will be open for 2 days.

Sonic can go die.

This is actually a three-way tie for third place, not a runoff vote for 2nd and 3rd. Only one game will advance. If anyone who already voted feels like this would have changed the way they voted, let me know (e.g. if you wouldn't have wanted your 2nd pick beating your 1st pick, when your 1st pick is really the main/only game you should have been able to boost). The voters eligible for this are WindFish91, Pluvus [1st vote UW], MerlinDrazziw [1st vote Sonic], Kong Wen [1st vote UW], Jordan.

Sonic was my first vote, Uncharted my second. You can remove my second vote.

Jordan wrote:Sonic can go die.

Sonic can go live.

I had a lot of fun with Sonic 2, really great music.

Uncharted first vote.

Rob

It pains me to not vote for Sonic 2 as it's the best game in the series and a childhood favorite, but Valkyria is one of the best and prettiest games of all time.

OK, if we adjust the votes for the people who opted only to have one of their votes count, the totals for this poll are:

Sonic the Hedgehog 2 with 8 votes minus Pluvius = 7
Uncharted Waters with 7 votes minus Merlin = 6
Valkyria Chronicles with 8 votes minus Kong = 7

Of the erroneous double-voters, only WindFish chose both Sonic and Valkyria. That means if he responds within the next 15 minutes, he can basically choose which game wins. Otherwise, I'm going to have to post a 1-day tie-breaker tie-breaker with Uncharted Waters removed.