Top 128 Tie-Breaker 5/8: Smash Metal Yoshi

[link64]

Yoshi's Island, I'm voting against MGS2.

Why's that?

I can't stand the game, I'm not a fan of conspiracy theory stories especially when there this ridiculous.

Also I really don't think it's well written at all.

[Sharecrow]

Yoshi's Island, I'm voting against MGS2.

Why's that?

I can't stand the game, I'm not a fan of conspiracy theory stories especially when there this ridiculous.

Also I really don't think it's well written at all.

That's a legitimate complaint about the MGS series as a whole and, indeed, why I no longer play them. It's silly but not in a humorous way and the writing is atrocious. MGS2, though, worked just due to environment and gameplay. I had so much fun with that game I could tolerate its egregious flaws. I think 1 worked as well though not quite as well. 3 didn't work for me and I can hardly bring myself to play 4 even though I bought it as one of my first PS3 games.

[link64]

I can't stand the game, I'm not a fan of conspiracy theory stories especially when there this ridiculous.

Also I really don't think it's well written at all.

That's a legitimate complaint about the MGS series as a whole and, indeed, why I no longer play them. It's silly but not in a humorous way and the writing is atrocious. MGS2, though, worked just due to environment and gameplay. I had so much fun with that game I could tolerate its egregious flaws. I think 1 worked as well though not quite as well. 3 didn't work for me and I can hardly bring myself to play 4 even though I bought it as one of my first PS3 games.

I actually really like MGS3, I just ignore all the stuff about The Philosophers and treat it like a 60s bond movie.

[Kong Wen]

Super Mario World 2: Yoshi's Island has defeated Metal Gear Solid 2 and Super Smash Bros. for Wii U to advance to the Top 128.